Peer Review Response Writer
Craft compelling, professional point-by-point responses to peer reviewer comments that maximize your manuscript's chances of acceptance. Covers cover letters to editors, diplomatic rebuttals, contradiction handling, and revision tracking.
SupaScore
83.95Best for
- ▸Crafting diplomatic responses to harsh peer reviewer criticisms of academic manuscripts
- ▸Writing strategic cover letters to journal editors highlighting major manuscript revisions
- ▸Handling contradictory reviewer demands while maintaining manuscript integrity
- ▸Converting valid reviewer feedback into compelling evidence-based rebuttals with citations
- ▸Structuring point-by-point response documents that maximize resubmission acceptance rates
What you'll get
- ●Strategic cover letter (300-500 words) summarizing key revisions with bullet points and diplomatically addressing disagreements
- ●Comprehensive point-by-point response document with quoted reviewer comments, specific responses, and exact manuscript changes with page numbers
- ●Professional rebuttal sections that graciously accept valid criticism while providing evidence-based counterarguments for disputed points
Not designed for ↓
- ×Writing the original research manuscript or conducting the research itself
- ×Choosing which journal to submit to or understanding journal submission systems
- ×Performing additional data analysis or experiments requested by reviewers
- ×Providing subject matter expertise in specific scientific disciplines
Peer review comments from journal reviewers along with the editor's decision letter and context about the manuscript's research area.
A complete response package including strategic cover letter to editor and detailed point-by-point reviewer responses with diplomatic language and revision tracking.
Evidence Policy
Enabled: this skill cites sources and distinguishes evidence from opinion.
Research Foundation: 8 sources (4 official docs, 2 academic, 1 industry frameworks, 1 books)
This skill was developed through independent research and synthesis. SupaSkills is not affiliated with or endorsed by any cited author or organisation.
Version History
Initial release
Works well with
Need more depth?
Specialist skills that go deeper in areas this skill touches.
Common Workflows
Academic Publication Pipeline
Complete manuscript development from technical writing through peer review response to conference presentation
Activate this skill in Claude Code
Sign up for free to access the full system prompt via REST API or MCP.
Start Free to Activate This Skill© 2026 Kill The Dragon GmbH. This skill and its system prompt are protected by copyright. Unauthorised redistribution is prohibited. Terms of Service · Legal Notice